Andrew Mosley
15 Nov
15Nov

It took me decades to realise that it was all the fault of The Famous Five.

My fascination with Enid Blyton's irritatingly posho quintet began when they were sent off for the Easter holidays to a place called Smuggler's Top, where they encountered some nefarious activity and a supposedly deaf servant called Block.

What could go wrong?

Nothing. That's the point. It's not real. It's not true.

I was about eight years old though, and Blyton's perfect world, where Julian, Dick, Anne, George and Timmy the Dog routinely uncovered illegal underground tunnel-based shenanigans before solving the crime and, unlike the police, ensuring the villains were brought to justice, seemed like an excellent way to spend a childhood.

Whether they were camping, hiking, exploring a treasure island, visiting Finniston Farm or trudging across Mystery Moor, the formula rarely changed. Dictatorial Julian, dependable Dick, tomboy George, girly Anne and the real hero, Timmy, would stumble into a plot involving smugglers, firearms, sinister criminals and assorted wrongdoers, respond with fearless derring-do, emerge victorious, celebrate with lashings of ginger beer (“No, no, not you Timmy, you’re a dog, you bothersome barking berk), then head back to Uncle Quentin and Aunt Fanny's luxury cottage on Kirrin Island.

Not once did any of them end up lying in a pool of blood, clutching a wound, or being led into rehab after developing a trauma-induced addiction to crack cocaine. 

As I devoured these stories, spending birthday money on copies bought for 50p apiece from a stall in Keighley Market, I found myself asking a simple question: why can't my life be like theirs?

At school you're told to follow your dreams and chase your ambitions. If I couldn't become a footballer or enjoy the inherited advantages of a top private-school education, Famous Five-type adventures with guaranteed happy endings seemed a perfectly reasonable alternative.

So off I went. I wandered around looking for the Yorkshire Ripper. Nothing. I broadened my ambitions to include other murderers. Still nothing. I suppose I could have attempted to apprehend the occasional shoplifter, but it would hardly have felt the same. Likewise, the perpetrators of random acts of violence, although I doubt many of them would have responded favourably to cries of: “Hey, you! Stop! Don't you know committing grievous bodily harm solves nothing?”

So what's the point? The point is that I was sold a lie by Blyton and her meddlesome creations, an unachievable dream that condemned me to a lifetime of bitterness and disappointment.

Fiction does exactly what the word suggests. Yet do writers, even in fiction, have some responsibility to tell the truth? Not factual truth. Emotional truth.

Most readers understand the bargain. They know they're stepping into a fantasy and that stories are not instruction manuals. Writers should trust readers to make that leap. But what happens if you don't? What if you don't read these books simply as tales about children solving crimes on holiday? What if you see them as a promise that life itself will somehow work out in the end? What if escapism isn't something you visit, but somewhere you desperately want to live?

Nothing should be written for universal appeal and every work, within reason, is open to interpretation. And for me, those books represented possibility.

Some people chase the lives they imagine for themselves and occasionally get there. Others, perhaps like the Famous Five might have in real life, go off the rails in pursuit of temporary happiness. Most of us end up somewhere else entirely: not necessarily where we wanted to be, but somewhere we have to accept, learn to appreciate and occasionally even enjoy.

And, as we were often told as kids, we're better off than most - but that doesn’t always ease the frustration.

Anyway, I never had a dog, but that’s another story.

Comments
* The email will not be published on the website.